Resources

$318,000 Federal Jury Verdict for a Property Owner Accused of Fraud by His Insurer

https://williamsattys.com/resources/understanding-your-legal-rights-after-an-accident
Williams & Williams attorney Melissa Mosier at her desk, looking out her office window.

Overview

Williams & Williams attorneys Maya Grace Slaughter and Melissa Mosier took a denied fire claim to a federal jury and won $318,000, the full amount of the policy, for a client the insurer had accused of fraud.

  • A South Carolina property owner's house burned to the ground. When he filed his claim, the insurance company refused to pay and accused him of fraud.
  • Williams & Williams attorneys Maya Grace Slaughter and Melissa Mosier brought a breach of contract claim against the insurer and tried the case to a jury in federal court.
  • The jury rejected the fraud accusation and awarded $318,000, the full amount of the policy.
  • In South Carolina, an insurer that wants to void apolicy for misrepresentation has to prove the policyholder lied on purpose. A denial letter is not the last word.

What happened

His house burned down, and the insurance company called him a fraud.

Our client is a local business owner. He was looking for an investment property, found a house that needed work, and saw potential in it.

He called an insurance company for a quote. The person on the other end of the line was a salesperson, and the call quickly turned into a sale. The questions asked on that call, and the way they were asked, would later decide the case.

Then the house burned to the ground.

When he filed his claim, the insurance company refused to pay. Instead of honoring the policy, it accused him of fraud, claiming he had misrepresented the property when he applied for coverage.

So he came to us. Attorneys Maya Grace Slaughter and Melissa Mosier brought a breach of contract claim against the insurer and took it to a jury in federal court.

The insurance company brought in the big guns

The insurance company decided to make an example of ourclient.

It started with the out-of-towners. Executives and experts flown in from across the company. The message to a South Carolina jury was plain: we have more people, more money, and more credentials than this man does.

Then it called the realtor who had helped our client buy the house. On the stand, the realtor said the place was dilapidated and that our client had added nothing to it.

It went after his name, too. The insurer dug up misdemeanor charges from decades earlier, with no connection to the house, the fire, or the claim, and tried to use them as if they proved something.

Its theory was fraud: our client had lied about the condition of the property to get the policy, so the insurer owed him nothing.

It failed, because our client wasn't alone.

Williams & Williams attorney Maya Grace Slaughter, center, reviews a case file with two colleagues in a law library.
Maya Grace Slaughter, center, with Destinee Merritt and Kacey Lupton of Williams & Williams Attorneys at Law.

How Williams & Williams leveled the playing field

The case came down to one question: did our client intend to deceive the insurance company? Under South Carolina law, that is the insurer's burden to prove. The evidence said no.

Here is what it looks like to fight for a client against anopponent with far deeper pockets.

  • ‍We pressure-tested their witnesses. The insurer put our client's own realtor on the stand to say he had added no value to the house. On cross-examination, the realtor admitted to never having set foot inside it.‍
  • We held their own people accountable. We questioned the insurer's underwriter, who had to admit the company had overvalued the house. The jury could draw the obvious conclusion: the insurer set the value high to collect higher premiums, then called the house worthless when it was time to pay.‍
  • We let the jury hear it for themselves. We played the recorded quote calls in open court. The jury heard a sales pitch, not an underwriting review. Nobody on that call was assessing a risk. They were closing a sale.‍
  • We set the record straight on our client's name. He is a hard worker and a business owner supporting a family of six. Mistakes from decades ago had nothing to do with whether the insurer owed what it promised. He did not deserve to be smeared. He deserved credit for how far he had come.

That's what it means to fight.

The verdict: $318,000

The jury found that the insurance company had breached its contract and awarded our client $318,000, the full amount of the policy. That is the full value of a house the insurer spent an entire trial insisting was worth nothing.

We out-maneuvered them, out-lawyered them, and out-tried them.

Strip away the experts and the executives, and this case was simple. An insurance company set a value, collected premiums on that value, and then, after the fire, decided it had made a bad deal and went looking for a way out. Powerful institutions have to be held to their promises. We made sure this one was.

Two points of South Carolina law made the difference. An insurer that accuses a policyholder of fraud has to prove he meant to deceive it, and the jury found he didn't. And when a house is a total loss by fire, the insurer owes the full amount it agreed to insure the house for, not whatever it decides the house was worth after the fire.

About Williams & Williams

Founded in Orangeburg, South Carolina, in 1936, Williams & Williams Attorneys at Law has served clients across the state for 90 years. Our attorneys are relentless advocates for justice, formidable in the courtroom and compassionate with the people and families they represent.

Learn more about attorneys Maya Grace Slaughter and Melissa Mosier.

Williams & Williams practices personal injury, civil litigation, and criminal defense from its Orangeburg office (1281 Russell St.,Orangeburg, SC 29115) and Columbia office (3104 Devine St., Columbia, SC 29205).

Call (803) 534-5218 or schedule a free consultation. Every consultation is conducted by a Williams & Williams attorney.‍

PRIOR RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE A SIMILAR OUTCOME. EVERY CASE IS DIFFERENT AND DEPENDS ON ITS OWN FACTS.

Related Articles

No related articles yet.
Browse all articles